Dog collars to avoid

An inappropriate collar can exacerbate these behavioral problems, making the dog even more nervous or reactive. That's why it's essential to know what types of collars to avoid for these dogs so as not to make their condition worse. Here's an in-depth look at the collars that can be problematic for both docile and anxious or aggressive dogs.

Note: All necklaces mentioned in this point are absolutely not recommended by our teams, we believe in positive and non-punitive education. Such collars (they are for the most part) should be banned from sale.

  1. The choke collar (or chain collar)

A choke collar, also called a chain collar , is a type of collar that tightens around a dog's neck when it pulls on the leash. While it is used by some owners to manage dogs that pull or exhibit reactive behaviors, it is strongly discouraged for anxious or aggressive dogs for several reasons:

  • Panic Effect : An anxious dog may panic when the collar suddenly tightens around his neck. This feeling of suffocation can cause further stress, reinforcing the dog's anxiety.
  • Injury Risks : Choke collars put excessive pressure on the dog's windpipe and neck, increasing the risk of physical injuries, such as throat injuries or nerve damage. This is especially dangerous for dogs that are already tense or reactive.
  • Increased Aggression : For aggressive dogs, a choke collar can make the problem worse by increasing their frustration level. A dog that feels trapped or in pain may react by becoming more aggressive, especially toward other dogs or bystanders.

  1. The spiked collar

The prong collar , also known as a prong collar or spiked collar, is designed to apply even pressure to a dog's neck when it pulls on the leash. Each "spike" presses lightly against the skin, simulating the natural correction dogs give each other by biting. However, for anxious or aggressive dogs, this collar poses considerable risks:

  • Pain and Discomfort : This collar is painful for the dog, especially when used excessively or incorrectly. For an already nervous or anxious dog, this pain can reinforce fears and create a negative association with the walk, the leash, or even the owner.
  • Defensive Behavior : When faced with pain, some aggressive dogs may adopt an increased defensive posture, feeling threatened. Instead of learning to calm down, these dogs may become even more reactive, attacking or growling more in situations where they already felt vulnerable.
  • Escalation effect : A dog that feels constantly attacked by his collar can enter a vicious cycle where his aggression intensifies, making it even more difficult to manage his behavior.

  1. The electronic collar (or impulse collar)

The electronic collar , also called a shock collar or impulse training collar , is used to correct behavior by sending a slight

electric shock or vibration to the dog. While this tool can be useful in some specific cases, it should absolutely be avoided for anxious or aggressive dogs:

  • Reinforcement of anxiety : For an already stressed or nervous dog, receiving an electric shock, even a mild one, can be traumatic. It only amplifies existing fears, sometimes leading to flight behaviors or trembling.
  • Increased risk of aggression : Dogs who experience these impulses without understanding why may become aggressive. They may associate the pain or discomfort with an external element (another dog, a person, a place) and react defensively or offensively in future encounters.
  • Emotional impact : The electronic collar can also create emotional distance between the owner and the dog. An anxious dog may begin to associate the presence of his owner with pain, which could damage the trusting relationship between them.

  1. Collars that are too tight or unsuitable

A collar that is too tight or ill-fitting can create constant pressure points on your dog's neck, which is especially harmful to anxious or aggressive dogs. Here's why it's crucial to make sure your collar fits properly:

  • Confined feeling : A collar that is too tight can make your dog feel like he is constantly being restricted, increasing his stress level. This feeling of confinement can cause agitation and make your dog more likely to react with aggressive or nervous behaviors.
  • Chronic pain : If the collar is not properly fitted, it can cause pain in the skin, muscles and cervical vertebrae. For anxious dogs, this chronic pain can reinforce avoidance or escape behaviors. For aggressive dogs, the pain can intensify their reactivity.

  1. Vibration or sound collars

Vibration or tone collars are sometimes used to correct unwanted behaviors. They emit either a loud noise or vibrations to interrupt behavior such as barking or biting. Although they may seem less aggressive than shock collars, they are not always appropriate for anxious or aggressive dogs:

  • Sensory overload : An anxious dog can be easily disturbed by the vibrations or noises emitted by this type of collar. Instead of calming the dog, it can worsen his stress level, making him even more nervous when faced with unpredictable noises or situations.
  • Confusion : These collars do not always allow the dog to understand what is expected of him. An anxious or aggressive dog, confronted with sounds or vibrations without a clear explanation, can become even more confused and react with unwanted behaviors, such as excessive barking or aggression.

  1. Why avoid these collars for dogs?

All of the above types of collars can intensify emotional and behavioral problems in anxious or aggressive dogs. Using a collar that causes pain, discomfort, or confusion only reinforces the negative emotions already present in the dog, making the problem more difficult to treat.

For these dogs, it is best to opt for gentle, progressive training methods, such as using softer collars or harnesses, and to seek the help of dog training professionals who specialize in managing dogs with anxious or aggressive behavior.

  1. Alternative Solutions for Anxious or Aggressive Dogs

For dogs suffering from anxiety or behavioral problems, it is recommended to favor less restrictive solutions that are more adapted to their needs:

  • No-Pull Harnesses : These harnesses allow for better control without putting pressure on the neck. They are designed to distribute pressure across the dog's body, reducing the risk of injury and discomfort. They are especially effective for dogs that pull on the leash and are often more tolerated by anxious or nervous dogs.
  • Nylon or fabric collars : Collars made from soft, lightweight materials can be a good compromise for dogs that don't like rigid collars. These collars should fit snugly, but should never be too tight on the dog's neck.
  • Positive training : Associating the use of the collar with positive rewards and experiences can help improve a dog's behavior without resorting to punitive techniques. By reinforcing good behaviors rather than punishing bad ones, anxious or aggressive dogs can gradually learn to adopt calmer, more balanced attitudes.
Back to Dog collar information